Stephen Tanzer (ST): 90
"Bright medium yellow. Ripe peach and nectarine aromas complicated by flowers, dusty brown spices and vanillin oak. Ripe and smooth on the palate, with an impression of dusty extract to the peach and floral flavors. This nicely balanced wine shows better flavor intensity and freshness in bottle than it did in barrel but is still in a rather easygoing, approachable style."
Burghound (BH): 91
"* Outstanding! * A ripe and overtly floral nose also speaks of white peach, pear and toasty oak that serve as an elegant introduction to the mineral-inflected, delicious and impressively rich middle weight flavors that possess excellent length where the wood also resurfaces. This refined effort is very Puligny in style and character."Allan Meadows Burghound